Leadership

Why one great hire won't pay down Leadership Debt

The problem usually isn't the person

When a plan stalls, the instinct is to find the function that broke. Sales missed, so look at the head of sales. Cash is tight, so look at finance. Sometimes that's right. More often, every leader in the room is doing their job, and the plan still stalls.

That's because most execution doesn't fail inside a function. It fails between them. In a Harvard Business Review study of 7,600 managers across 262 companies, only 9 percent said they could rely on colleagues in other functions all the time. In the same research, only 55 percent of middle managers could name even one of their company's top five priorities.

Nobody in those companies was bad at their job. The space between the jobs had no owner. That gap is what we call Leadership Debt: it builds through growth, not failure, and it comes due at the worst moments.

Three places Leadership Debt hides

  1. 1.

    Decisions that wait for one person. Work slows whenever the CEO or one key leader is out, because the team has learned that decisions made without them get reversed.

  2. 2.

    Work that spans two functions with no owner. Pricing that touches sales and finance. A product launch that touches product, marketing and operations. Ask who owns it. If the answer takes more than five seconds, or it's a committee, the plan will stall there.

  3. 3.

    Leaders doing a job twice the size of the one they were hired for. The company grew. The seat grew with it. The person in it is working harder than anyone and is still the bottleneck.

Why replacing one leader under-delivers

Replacing an executive is the most common fix, and sometimes it's the right one. But it's slow, and it addresses one seat. AlixPartners' 2026 private equity leadership survey found 65 percent of PE firms report CEO turnover during the hold. A strong new leader still can't make the product team answer the revenue team on their own. The debt sits in the seams, and the seams belong to everyone.

What actually pays it down

Leadership Debt gets paid down when someone owns the seams. That means three things:

  • A clear read of where capacity is short: which seats, which handoffs, which decisions.
  • Experienced operators deployed against those gaps, coordinated by one accountable lead rather than three independent consultants.
  • A planned handoff, so the capability stays after the outside help leaves.

At The Proper Group we call this model Collective Leadership as a Service, or CLaaS. A coordinated group of seasoned operators from a bench of 200 and growing embeds across the seams, typically for 6 to 18 months, through three steps: Diagnose, Design, Deploy. Then they hand a working system back to your team.

When TPG is not the right call

  • The problem really is one function. If revenue, finance and operations are working together fine and one seat is simply empty, hire for the seat.
  • You need a permanent leader and have time to search. A retained search firm is the better choice.
  • You want a report, not an operator. If your team will execute the plan itself, a consulting firm or independent advisor may suit you better.

The Proper Group

The Proper Group is a national collective, headquartered in Cincinnati, that places senior operating executives inside companies at the moments the current team can't carry: cash pressure, a missed plan, a closed deal, a leader gone. One accountable lead runs the team, the executive who diagnoses the problem can embed to fix it, and every engagement is built to hand off to the client's own leaders.

Frequently asked questions

What is Leadership Debt?

The gap between what a growing company now needs from its leadership and what its leadership structure was built to do. It builds through growth and shows up as slow decisions, stalled cross-functional work and overloaded leaders.

Is Leadership Debt a talent problem?

Usually not. Strong leaders can carry Leadership Debt when the company outgrows the structure around them. It's mostly a capacity and coordination problem.

How do I know if my company has it?

Look for decisions that wait on one person, cross-functional work with no single owner, and leaders whose jobs have doubled. The Proper Read measures it in about three minutes.

What is CLaaS?

Collective Leadership as a Service: The Proper Group's model of embedding a coordinated team of experienced operators across a company's leadership gaps, with a planned transfer back to the permanent team.

Next step: Find out where your leadership capacity is running short. The Proper Read takes about three minutes and shows results on screen.

Take The Proper Read

Sources

All insights